Peter Chapman: Jungle Capitalists: A Story of Globalisation, Greed and Revolution
Charts the economic rise and pervasive political influence of the first globalised company - the US United Fruit Company, precursor for the activities of today's multinationals. By building railways and the acquisition of land rights from central American states it created monopoly banana production and determined the politics of the region. By the 1930's the company had created a "vast feudal state" of plantations, worker settlements and client governments scattered across central America. The simple Banana may have been the product, but to ensure its continued profitability (ie keeping production costs low and free from native involvement) United Fruit was not averse to heavy involvement in agressive politics. Support for coups was common, most clearly seen in the 1929 Santa Marta massacre of 1000+ demonstrators in Colombia and the Guatamalan coup of 1954. But Guatamala backfired - it frightened the US government into starting anti trust procedures that would see United Fruit shrink into "Chiquita" in the 1980's; Ernesto Guevara witnessed the coup and it helped convince him of the need to use force to gain national freedom; the US press, heavily manipulated by United Fruit decided to pursue more personally investigative styles in future (Herbert Matthews went off in search of Castro on a personal quest for "truth" which was to give such positive press for Castro in the US). However the author warns for today: Chiquita has admitted to paying nearly $2 million to right-wing death squads in Colombia and Chapman cites the example of Costa Rica, (the only central American country to escape United Fruit and create a more welfare-orientated state) where modern multinationals working within a free-market economy are causing severe problems of social inequality. This book is timely and testimony to the survival of United Fruit and how well it has continued to cover its tracks outside latin America. May '08 (****)
Giles MacDonogh: After the Reich
There is a fuller review as a post ("After the Reich") Any modern writer of post war Germany who mentions the names of Hajo Holborn and Michael Balfour in the first few pages clearly has done their reading. This book fills in the gap left in many English language histories of postwar central Europe: from the actual end of war and its immediate impact to the outbreak of the Cold War. Covering not just the zones of Germany, but also Austria and the events of German speaking Europe elsewhere - the German Reich at its largest.Since the Wende, this has been a topic occupying the history shelves of most German bookshops. MacDonogh has done English readers a service with this account. The underlying sentiment is that this book records the consequences of the far greater evil perpetrated on others by the Germans - a feeling that many of those recorded reflect, despite their misery. It is not surprising that with the opening of the east Germans have wished to document the period, nor is it surprising that Anglo-saxon writers have shunned it for so long. May '06
(*****)
Robert Carver: Paradise with Serpents
Carver's travel tales of Paraguay in 2001-2 see him comparing it with amongst others, the Congo, Albania, and the one I like best: pre partition 18th century Poland.... In places amusing, in others sadly pathetic this is a good companion to John Gimlettes Inflatable Pig (which has a more historical focus and which Carver is gracious enough to praise). Carver is well read and this gives a depth to his stories as well as allowing him to put modern Paraguay in a context with its neighbours. Starting off an enthusiastic investigative tourist, Carver ends desperate to leave and running for a seat on one of the few planes out of Paraguay for São Paulo. It may be good armchair adventure but I am not sure if this will encourage less intrepid tourists to travel far beyond Ciudad del Este though! April '08 (***)
Charles McKean: Battle for the North: The Tay and Forth Bridges and the 19th-Century Railway Wars
Outlines the late 19th century railway rivalry between the Caledonian and North British railway companies that produced the two famous rail bridges over the Tay and Forth. Well detailed but perhaps too focussed on the minutiae of the boardroom disputes that lay behind the first Tay Bridge. Conversely it does Bouch a service in highlighting the role of fatigue in bringing down his Tay Bridge. Probably best read by someone with more than a nodding acquaintance to Jute era Dundee. Knowing Dundee I found this of interest, but the lay reader might not. A health warning is perhaps needed on the jacket. One last point. Good to see so many illustrations, but the maps are terrible. March '08 (**)
Max Hastings: Nemesis (US title:Retribution): The Battle for Japan, 1944-45
Another massive tome, this time on the final 18 months of the Pacific War. An overall synthesis, easily laid out with different theatres given seperate chapters. I found the most useful sections to be on those areas of conflict often less publicised in the west (& Europe. eg Burma, Australia, China, the sub war) By contrast, Macarthurs travails through the Philippines are less compulsive (as the man himself appears to have been). Some key points emerge: the (very) variable quality of US military commanders (FDR seems to have given them an almost free hand), the Japanese disinterest in technology (!!) and the early (quite considerable) failings of the B29. March '08 (****)
Ian W. Toll: Six Frigates: The Epic History of the Founding of the U.S. Navy
A huge tome that tells the story of the origins of the US Navy (It started with just 6 frigates...) in the late 18th/early 19th century. Written by a journalist rather than a historian so is not quite a US N.A.M. Rodgers but is well written and reads easily. Still it is perhaps one for the ship anorak rather than the general reader. Interesting to see the early potential wealth of the newly independent US: able to build a fleet and a state capital at the same time! Equally valuable are the links drawn at the end that connect this early growth directly to the Monroe doctrine and Thedore Roosevelts Great White fleet. Feb '07 (***)
Ben Elton: Blind Faith
Set in a flooded, overcrowded and globally warmed future this is a cutting, clever, satire on present face-booked, celeb and fame obsessed society from the writer of Black Adder. I do not usually include Eltons on this list, (with one exception) but this one is a worthwhile addition. A quick read and amusing but thought provoking. In addition to Elton's usually socially perceptive concepts, this one has the added advantage of having a worthwhile ending and less of the gratuitous sex, rock 'n roll..... Feb '08 (****)
Jessica Warner: Craze: Gin and Debauchery in an Age of Reason
Warner writes about the English (London?) gin "epidemic" of the early 18th century. As a piece of social history it is of value, well supported and argued (perhaps too drily though - this has the air of an academic work tweaked to do a Sobel "Longtitude" for a mass market). What is most surprising though is the way the argument shows that the issue was one focussed on women, and that it was the poorest women who emerge as the biggest victims economically as well as socially from the expansion of gin drinking as well as from its ever tighter control (they did most of the streetside selling). The big distillers/publicans were men.... they continued to survive, and were not locked up to the same extent. Dec '07 (**)
Frederick Taylor: The Berlin Wall: A World Divided, 1961-1989
An interesting narrative of the history of the Berlin Wall by the autthor of Dresden. Like that earlier work much attention is given to context (although the potted history of the pre 1961 Cold War period is perhaps too potted). The Wall remains the focus, especially in the 1960's highlighting as it does the hypocrisy and lack of will of the western powers and the federal republic to support their rhetoric with action towards the east (which was probably the wise course...) But the most satisfactory chapter is perhaps the final one with insights and perceptions available only to a writer with a genuine affection and knowledge of the east gained through personal association. Useful also to anyone seeking an accessible, and general history of the GDR. One final point - in my (hardback) edition there are a surprising number of typos, signs perhaps of too swift editing. But why? Dec '07 (***)
Mike Dash: Batavia's Graveyard: The True Story of the Mad Heretic Who Led History's Bloodiest Mutiny
This is the story of the 1629 Batavia mutiny of the Dutch East India Company (VOC). The (eventually quite horrific) story of shipwreck off modern Australia, mutiny, then "Lord of the Flies" type conflict between the shipwrecked survivors is well told, and equally provides a clear general insight into the workings of the VOC and the early routes to the east. The final section interestingly brings the story up to the present (despite a poor psycho-babble conclusion on the main character). There are a few caveats however: initially the book digresses too much from the story to talk of 17th century ships and trade in general. My edition had a third (over 100 pages) devoted to useful footnotes, but no numbering was given in the text - you had to look at the back in the "off chance" there may be a footnote and a statement was founded in history, not supposition..... Some illustrations would also be useful... Nov '07 (***)
Simon Sebag Montefiore: Young Stalin
This has to be read by anyone who seriously wants to understand what made Stalin tick. The account of his youth and formative years (up to Oct/Nov 1917) clearly indicates the impact of growing up in the wilds of (still lawless and gangster riddled) Georgia and the Caucasus. Sebag Montefiore's account does more though - it explains perhaps the ease with which the USSR slid into oligarchy and lawlessness in the 1990's - because of a general underlying tradition of violence, but also the dangers of faith schools and the risks of encarcerating enemies of the state in similar places. Stalin? More educated and culturally rounded than I had thought, but presents as not a pleasant character at all - easy to understand his purges and ruthlessness as later USSR leader. Equally repugnant seemed to be his inclination towards impregnating teenage girls at least half his age - one of whom was only 13, (he was in his 30's......) Very readable nonetheless. Oct '07 (****)
Paul Blustein: And the Money Kept Rolling In (and Out): Wall Street, the IMF, and the Bankrupting of Argentina
A readable account of the 2001-2 Argentine economic crash and how it emerged out of the growth of the 1990's. And at the end, where does Blustein point the finger of blame? To be sure, slack Argentine policies throughout the period and the impetuosity finally of Cavallo (where was President de la Rua at the time?) carry much of the final responsibility for the eventual collapse. However he argues that the real culprits are the international bankers - too willing to lend, to convince the Argentine government to issue more & more bonds and to push rates of repayment ever higher. The IMF? Blustein sees them as being blinded by what he calls "poster-child syndrome" ie unwilling to be tough & give unwelcome advice and support (especially post 1998) other then more loans, when "tough love" rather than more debts was needed by the country it had over-promoted as the free market success of the 1990's. Sept '07 (***)
Edward Pearce: The Great Man: Sir Robert Walpole: Scoundrel, Genius and Britain's First Prime Minister
Well reviewed tome on the 18th century prime minister. However, despite that I found the style tedious, not to say affected, with its large number of subordinate clauses (very Germanic - perhaps this is an attempt to produce a hanoverian style???). Nor does the amount of snide sniping at other historians help as this undermines the regard for the new material and ideas provided by Pearce. A shame as this (not necessarily likeable) character deserves a better presented modern treatment. Disappointing. Sept '07 (**)
Giles Tremlett: Ghosts of Spain: Travels Through Spain and Its Secret Past
Written by The Guardians Spain reporter this is a guide to help the anglo-saxon understand modern Spain by attempting to explain the history - ancient & modern - that is its foundation. Tremlett, as a long term resident writes with insight and real understanding - and at length. His best chapters are the early ones when he explains the secretos a voces originating from the Franco era and the "amnistía and amnesia" that followed it. He rationalises the dichotomy whereby Spains prosecutors are the most fervent in chasing up the perpetrators of Latin Americas military regimes whilst (until recently at least) ignoring the events of their own right wing period. Unfortunately the book will be too wordy to be read by most anglosajóns on the costas - tighter editing might have broadened its appeal - and value. (Sept '07) (***)
Ben Macintyre: Agent Zigzag: A True Story of Nazi Espionage, Love, and Betrayal
A quick holiday read but no less enjoyable for that. Macintyres account of the double agent Eddie Chapman is told well and in a sympathetic way - this despite the many initially questionable aspects of the man himself. Chapman, Agent Zigzag, a habitual criminal and serial womaniser/romancer became a spy for the German Abwehr then a double agent (of considerable value) for MI5. What is still unclear at the end is Chapman's motivation. Given the apparent complexities of his personality that may never be clear. As Le Carre is quoted in the blurb "meticulously researched, splendidly told and often very moving" especially in his loyalty to old friends. August '07 (***)
Thomas E. Ricks: Fiasco: The American Military Adventure in Iraq
Written by a veteran war correspondent this is the most depressing piece of writing to show very clearly and exhaustively just how incompetent and unprepared the US govt and military was/is for the Iraq war. Ricks is very painstaking in his research and the real degree of the fiasco becomes clearer and clearer as each page of tight text unfolds. A couple of caveats: the book could have done with a little more editing as the catalogue of recorded failings grows & grows (If time is short the first 200 of 440 are the most telling). Equally it needs to be remembered it is a piece of journalism, not history (but will become a valuable historical document iteself for its interviews) and this comes through in places in style and presentation. Ultimately the question the reader is left with is how little grasp of affairs & ability the US Presidency had/has and how little (informed) leadership it provided - and how genuinely unpleasant and ill educated key advisers were. August '07
(****)
Adrian Tinniswood: The Verneys: A True Story of Love, War and Madness in Seventeenth-Century England
Based on the massive 17th century Verney correspondence collection this gives a unique insight into the trials & joys of a well to do English gentry family. Tinniswood's Verneys are presented in a very readable narrative - a historical soap - with well judged asides to provide context to the general reader (if a little irritating to a specialist). Three aspects are made especially clear: the constant presence of mortality; the impact of civil war at a family level; the significance of social networking. Equally the book traces a clear change in the pattern of political power: from court based patronage, to the political corruption of early party politics and the emergence of trade based influence. Grass roots history at its most enjoyable. Maybe there are enough later letters for an 18th century follow up? July '07 (***)
Jonathan Fenby: Alliance: The Inside Story of How Roosevelt, Stalin and Churchill Won One War and Began Another
Meticulously detailed this looks exhaustively (at times perhaps too much so unless you are using this to research an essay!!) at the development of the WW2 alliance system. Several points emerge very clearly: that Teheran was probably the key meeting - Yalta was a case of formalising what had already been decided. Secondly, the emergence of Stalin as the main player with the support of FDR. Equally it is a surprise how many of the leading US & UK participants were in poor health, not just FDR but also many aides and military figures. As for Churchill he seemed unable to get Gallipoli out of his system, but was right in his postwar fears. For the publisher: why no maps? They would have been really helpful to envisage the logistics of the meetings. A false economy. June '07 (***)
Philip Roth: The Plot Against America: A Novel
An intriguing piece of counterfactual history - FDR loses the 1940 election to a right wing Lindbergh in league with Nazi Germany. Written in the first person from the viewpoint of a 10 year old boy this is perceptive and emotionally moving on a personal as well as social and political level as it charts the gradual decline of the US into antisemitic persecution. Yes, you can see how it might happen in a "civilised" society.... May '07 (****)
Sarah Helm: A Life in Secrets: Vera Atkins and the Missing Agents of WWII
This story of Vera Atkins, responsible for sending British female secret agents to Nazi France and her cathartic efforts to find out what happened to those who did not return is a compelling, well crafted read. The Atkins life is full of twists and page turning mysteries. However in the process Helm emphasizes the bravery of those sent to France and the amateur incompetence of those who sent them. Equally, the transparent nature of the books structure serves as an excellent example of how history is laboriously researched and worked upon using a variety of sources – in this case very much like a detective thriller. March ´07 (****)
Antonia Fraser: Love and Louis XIV
Fraser provides a feminine (as opposed to feminist) look at the reign of Louis XIV. Although it presents an interesting glimpse into the court life of the Sun King, it also reveals the dissolute and egocentric lifestyle of a royalty and nobility whose existence depended on the finances taken from the large tax base provided by a wealthy, absolutist state and from subjects they had little, or wished to have little in common with. Two points emerge ultimately: a better understanding of the future revolutionaries of 1789 and an intriguing glimpse of what might have been in England had such absolutism not been halted in 1642. Jan'07 (***)
Joseph Conrad: Heart of Darkness (Penguin Modern Classics)
The early 20th century novella stands up well with its account of Marlows journey in search of Kurtz. Its allusions to Stanley & the European exploitation of the Congo and its serving as the basis for Coppola's Apocolypse Now means there is plenty to think about. It is a long time since I have read an annotated Penguin classic of which this is an excellent example. Robert Hampson's Introduction and copious notes help greatly with understanding Conrad's nuances and probable intentions. Dec '06 (****)
John le Carre: The Mission Song
Latest novel stays in Africa like the Constant Gardener. This time the action centres on the Congo where le Carre weaves a plot involving western government subterfuge and mercenary activity. Not quite up to the standard of the Constant Gardener, but a thoughtful read putting the helplessness of Africans in the face of war & exploitation into sharp focus. this is another book I have read recently with references to Conrad's Heart of Darkness... maybe that should figure next. Dec '06 (***)
J.G. Ballard: Kingdom Come
An intriguing premise as always with Ballard - in this case his previous preoccupations with group psychology and behaviour focus this time on suburban shopping mall society. He creates a scenario plausible in contemporary England where motorways grid up at weekends as people go off to shop en masse in huge shopping centres. Unfortunately the plot is flawed by a rather confused portrayal of the central character. Worth a read, but not Ballard's best. Dec '06 (**)
William Golding: The Inheritors
This fifty year old follow-up to Lord of the Flies stands up well. Uses the clever device of being (largely) seen in the first person through the eyes of the slow, but well meaning neandertals as they make catastrophic first contact with our less personable and more agressive ancestors, homo sapiens. At times this methodology makes for a difficult read but the story of this first genocide as homo sapiens searched for expansion and power is just as true today as it was in the post Nazi world, unfortunately. Nov '06 (***)
David Sinclair: Sir Gregor Macgregor and the Land That Never Was
Story of a 19th century Scots fraudster, Gregor MacGregor and his scheme to make a fortune selling land in a non existent country in central America. The tale is an interesting one covering the MacGregors exploits in the Americas (where he fought alongside Miranda and Bolivar) and Europe as well as in Britain, but more judicious editing (especially of the independence campaigns MacGregor actually fought in) with a greater use of footnotes might make it both more useful to historians and efficient to read. Nov '06 (**)
Ronald Wright: A short history of progress
This is a concise primer for all who want to see just how fragile human life & society really is. Wright shows clearly just how brief our “civilised” existence has been and also how easily it could end. He does this by looking at key previous civilisations: Sumer, Rome, China, Mayan America and Easter Island. Clear, sobering lessons are drawn out for us to be learned if we are not to over-farm, pollute or destroy the present. He concludes with an Argentine saying: “Each night God cleans up the mess the Argentines make by day” but makes it clear that we are now at the point where God alone cannot clean up our mess. We can help ourselves, but only if we act now.
Excellent detailed footnotes develop the brevity of the presented arguments – and provide suggestions to a variety of further background reading. This should be a compulsory matriculation present for all school leavers…… Oct ´06
(*****)
Carlos Ruiz Zafon: The Shadow of the Wind
An enjoyable read. Has a touch of Susskind's Perfume about it as this neo-gothic story within a story unfolds in dark post civil war Barcelona. Ideally needs to be read fairly swiftly as the characters are numerous and the twists keep coming. The English translation is worth remarking upon – flowing and with a good turn of phrase (“the heavens were weeping” to describe rain at a funeral). I do not know if the translation is accurate, but it reads as if it were not one…. Oct '06 (***)
S D Levitt & S J Dubner: Freakonomics
This amusing & interesting read reminded me of the best of my Economics lessons so many years ago. We did little to no maths but much on the quirky reasoning behind many Economics theories and their outcomes. (our grades were not good, but they probably were the lessons I learned most from.) This book is full of these - it applies Economics reasoning to modern social issues. I liked the connection between the Ku Klux Klan's demise & Superman. Everyone who is not yet a parent and wants to be one later should read chapters 5 & 6 before they are. If you are already one it is too late to read them.... A little too US focussed perhaps and at times lends itself to speed reading (!) but a worthwhile read. Oct '06 (***)
Peter Nichols: Evolution's Captain
The story of Robert FitzRoy who took Darwin around the world. FitzRoy's life is shown as tragedy, from his early attempt to "civilise" the natives of Tierra del Fuega to his realisation that having facilitated Darwin produced the massive attack by Science on his own fundamentalist beliefs. Written not by a historian with an understanding of the sea but by a yachtsman with a sound grasp of the history this is a very readable account - although the paperback is much in need of a good map of Patagonia! Sept '06 (***)
Anonymous: A Woman in Berlin
This diary, written by a Berlin woman in her 30's during the fall of Berlin illustrates clearly and forcefully the real meaning of defeat. Interesting asides on the nature of the Russian conquerors: raised in a society where they received but could not choose they had little concept of "value", even of booty. Most of all it reveals the commonplace nature & acceptance of rape or of attaching oneself to an Ivan lover - for protection and survival. A very human diary of survival in year zero. Sept '06 (****)
Robert Harvey: The Liberators
Sympathetic & comprehensive narrative of the latin American Wars of Independence. Gave a new appreciation & respect for the social values of Bolivar and San Martin especially. Unfortunately, all were unappreciated in the ensuing states that they fought for - in particular by the criolla landowning families who undermined their reforms thus creating the years of chaos that followed - very much to the present. A worthy reference on the period but too heavy on military details for the general reader and limited on recent Spanish language scholarship. Aug '06 (***)
Tomás Eloy Martínez: The Tango Singer
A short but intriguing novel set in 2001 from Eloy Martínez, a writer whose work battles between history and literature. Whereas 'Santa Evita' (****) and The 'Perón Novel' (****) saw history dominant, here it is the literary side that provides an (ale-gorical?) framework for an almost mystical search through the horrors of Argentina's recent history. Best read if you have a knowledge of Buenos Aires and Borges - and a map handy!. July '06 (***)
Nigel Farndale: Haw-Haw : The Tragedy of William and Margaret Joyce
Tells the story of Lord Haw Haw (William Joyce), the wartime broadcaster from Germany, later hanged for treason in Britain. Presents Joyce as a tragic figure with strongly held (if seriously flawed) beliefs. I had not been aware of his (and for a while dominant) role in British interwar fascism, made clear in the book. Much writing is devoted to the time in wartime Berlin - and the experiences of their living as a couple in an alien environment with limited grasp of the language...... His postwar trial nonetheless is shown as a vengeful travesty of British justice - which Joyce accepts with grace (and perhaps a little enigmatic comfort from MI5..... - are the secret MI5 files on Joyce's possible work with them still closed?). June '06 (***)
N.A.M. Rodger: Safeguard of the Sea : A Naval History of Britain Vol 1 660-1649
Monumental (691 pages!!) first volume in the excellent Naval History of Britain. Likely to be used more as a reference than as a a book to read (unlike the very readable Vol II) this has much of interest and value. Debunks the rounded military leaderships of William I & Edward I. It shows very clearly the emergence of naval structure & power in Elizabethan times - and the origins of the English pirate stealing from the Spanish pirate.... More surprising perhaps is the real contribution Charles I's Ship money made to the Navy Royal. One quibble, despite claims to the contrary it is very anglocentric; Scottish marine developments are crucial but are generally en passant. May '06 (****)
Luis Sepulveda: The Name of a Bullfighter
Dark plot which ranges from the seedy Reeperbahn of Hamburg to Chile's Patagonia as cold warriors and retired guevarista leftists race to find a horde of gold hidden by SS refugees in south America..... Post modernist Boys Own stuff I'm afraid. April '06 (*)
Marina Lewycka: A Short History of Tractors in Ukrainian : A Novel
Plot outline suggests an interesting narrative, but does not live up to this promise. Limited character development and very UK focussed. April '06 (*)

Baby boomers, (like the cafe author it has to be admitted) hired in large numbers during a huge expansion in higher education that continued into the '70s, are being replaced by younger staff.
The New York Times has just completed a survey of nearly 50 US academics. Those interviewed believe the new intake are different from their predecessors — less ideologically polarized and more politically moderate. "There's definitely something happening," said Peter W. Wood, executive director of the National Association of Scholars, which was created in 1987 to counter attacks on Western culture and values. "I hear from quite a few faculty members and graduate students from around the country. They are not really interested in fighting the battles that have been fought over the last 20 years."
Already there are signs that the intense passions and polemics that rocked US campuses during the past couple of decades have begun to fade. At Stanford a divided anthropology department reunited last year after a bitter split in 1998 broke it into two entities, one focusing on culture, the other on biology. At Amherst, where military recruiters were kicked out in 1987, students crammed into a lecture hall this year to listen as alumni who served in Iraq urged them to join the military.
In general, information on professors' political and ideological leanings tends to be scarce. But a new study of the social and political views of American professors by Neil Gross at the University of British Columbia and Solon Simmons at George Mason University (described in detail in the lengthy New York Times article) found that the notion of a generational divide is more than a glancing impression. "Self-described liberals are most common within the ranks of those professors aged 50-64, who were teenagers or young adults in the 1960s," they wrote, making up just under 50 percent. At the same time, the youngest group, ages 26 to 35, contains the highest percentage of moderates, some 60 percent, and the lowest percentage of liberals, just under a third. When it comes to those who consider themselves "liberal activists," 17.2 percent of the 50-64 age group take up the banner compared with only 1.3 percent of professors 35 and younger. "These findings with regard to age provide further support for the idea that, in recent years, the trend has been toward increasing moderatism," the study says.
But as scholars across fields argue, the historical era in which a generation develops — the Depression, wartime or peaceful affluence — is a defining moment for its members. "My generational paradigm is the end of the cold war," said Matthew Woessner, a 35-year-old conservative and political scientist at Penn State Harrisburg. The notion that campuses are naturally radical or the birthplace of social movements, Ms. Kelly-Woessner said, was specific to the 1960s and '70s. "I think the younger generation does look at it differently."
And so it should - different generations, different viewpoints and interpretations: especially about a recent past. As for me some of my history students today visit the university I attended - then, in the early 70's it was left wing and pretty radical in politics and its subject offer. Now? it is fairly traditional, matter of fact and its most radical department is no longer Social Sciences, but probably Meteorology & Global Warming - but that is an issue worth going to the barricades for, 21st century style.
image origin post source: New York Times
linked casahistoria site: Teaching History
................................................................................................................
This morning in a fit of marking-induced madness I started to sing "Jesus wants me for a sunbeam" a tune stuck somewhere in the depths of memory that I used to sing as a youngster at a holiday Band of Hope session I the north of Scotland. I also remembered that I was awarded a badge for reciting biblical verses in between the singing (it had the dove flying back to the ark on it!!) that I wore on my lapel when I went back to school. I used to like badges one of my favourites was my Ian Allen loco spotters badge – a rarity at the time as it was made not from the usual tin but of…..plastic!!
Now it seems Obama has started wearing a lapel badge too but not a dove, or a blue plastic loco and tender, rather he has become the latest to sport the national flag on his chest. The origin of the flag lapel pin is murky. According to Mark Leepson's Flag: An American Biography, the "near religious reverence many Americans have" for our national symbol dates only to the Civil War era (not back to the Revolutionary War, as many assume) . Prior to that, few private citizens possessed or flew their own flags — it was limited to military and federal facilities. When the Confederates started winning battles early on in the War Between the States, Northerners began to fly the flag as a sign of pride.
Since then, flag imagery has been intricately tied to moments of crisis or conflict. Over the past four decades, Kit Hinrichs, one of the nation's top graphic designers, has collected more than 5,000 pieces of stars and stripes–related memorabilia. He says the flag lapel pins in his collection don't really date back before mid-century. "I don't think it was a common thing for men and women to wear before the Second World War," he says. "I certainly have jewelry from before then with flags on it — cufflinks and stick pins and tuxedo buttons and brooches — but not [many flag pins] before the '50s."
It was during the culture wars of the late '60s and early '70s that the flag lapel pin truly took off and became the simultaneously uniting and divisive symbol that it is today. Republican candidates in the 1970 congressional race wore them as a symbol of patriotic solidarity against anti-Vietnam protesters like Abbie Hoffman — who donned a shirt made of the flag — or others who stitched the flag onto the seat of their pants. But it was Richard Nixon who brought the pin to national attention. According to Stephen E. Ambrose's biography Nixon, the President got the idea for sporting a lapel pin from his chief of staff, H.R. Haldeman, who had noticed a similar gesture in the Robert Redford film The Candidate. Nixon commanded all of his aides to go and do likewise. The flag pins were noticed by the public, and many in Nixon's supposed "silent majority" began to similarly sport flags on their lapels. Over the next few decades, the pin sporadically surged in popularity. During the Gulf War, they sold briskly alongside flag patches and yellow ribbons.
Then came 9/11. Taking a page from the Nixon Administration, George W. Bush and his aides all donned pins. So did many anchors on Fox News, though not Bill O'Reilly, who said at the time "I'm just a regular guy. Watch me and you'll know what I think without wearing a pin." ABC News, on the other hand, prohibited its on-air
reporters from pinning on the red, white, and blue, citing a desire to maintain journalistic credibility.
As befits a tradition that reached its height during the Nixon years, flag lapel pins have — fairly or not — become to many a shibboleth of America's War on Terror, and a symbol of the "either you're with us or against us" ethos that has often prevailed since September 11, 2001. And while the USA hasn't yet reached anything close to a consensus on what a flag pin says about its wearer, Barack Obama seems to have discovered that symbols matter.
Bet he wishes he had a blue plastic Ian Allen loco spotters badge though….
image origin (top) (lower) post source: Time
................................................................................................................
As China winds up towards the Olympics and its spin doctors get into top gear, how much of its recent history will actually get a balanced presentation. or put another way, what type of China will be put on view?
Indeed, as China has become a global economic powerhouse, and as millions of Chinese pursue the goal of getting rich fast, there doesn't seem to be much of a demand to re-examine past events here, to study them fully and, in that way, to arrive at a clearer self-understanding.
No doubt, sitting quietly in their living rooms, there are not a few people in China pondering the lessons of events like the anti-rightist campaign of 1957, in which tens of thousands were sent off to labor camps, the disastrous Great Leap Forward that followed, and the Cultural Revolution itself, an episode of political fanaticism that would seem worthy of careful scrutiny.
Still, history is a delicate, carefully supervised matter in China, as is the news. China, on the one hand, has harshly criticized other countries over the years, especially Japan, for having a short memory regarding the atrocities it committed in China during its years of occupation. On the other hand, no country has a shorter memory than China when it comes to anything that might tarnish the reputation or the prestige of the governing party. No unrestricted historical inquiry is allowed in China, certainly no unrestricted debate among scholars on any of the sensitive topics, from the famine of the early 1960s to the student-led pro-democracy demonstrations of 1989 to the historical status of Tibet. When it comes to pictures, the authorities exercise tight control over government photographic archives, basically shutting down access to entire stretches of this country's recent past.
One rectifier may be a new publication from Taschen: a Chinese history in photographs that is published this month. It is "China: Portrait of a Country," edited by Liu Heung Shing, a former Time magazine and Associated Press photographer who has been living off and on in the country for the last 30 years. About 30 percent of the photographs in the book, Liu says, have never been published before, mainly because they depict events that the Chinese censors would prefer that the public forget - or, if not forget exactly, file away in a box in the musty attic of the collective consciousness that it's best not to reopen. And that's why Liu's book, which is being simultaneously published in Europe, America and Japan - but not in China - emerges as a veritable reconstruction of an otherwise disappearing pictorial history of China's last 60 years. It contains dozens of images, no longer available in China itself, showing how turbulent and brutal that history was - and how recently China was still a country not of shopping centers and Olympic Games, but of raw revolutionary violence.
To get around the closed archives, Liu spent years traveling China to collect pictures from dozens of Chinese photojournalists who had private archives of images of the major events of the last 60 years, and it is these pictures that make up the heart of his new book. And so, among the pictures you won't see in any official Chinese publications is one by Wang Shilong, who worked for a newspaper in China's northeast, showing the burning of old books by a mob in Henan Province in 1972. There's Jiang Shaowu's photograph from the late 1960s showing intellectuals and disgraced officials being "re-educated" in an "ox-shed" - so known because the offenders were called "ox-demons and snake spirits" during the campaign to rectify their bourgeois thinking. There's a picture from 1966 by Meng Zhaorui, a photographer for the army, showing Mao, Lin Biao and Premier Zhou Enlai together working on a speech that Lin was about to give in support of Mao to a Red Guard rally in Tiananmen Square, in Beijing.
And there are dozens of other images that will strike many readers as unforgettable, even if China seems well on course toward doing what the government wants, which is precisely to forget them.
image origin post source: Herald Tribune
linked casahistoria site: Mao's China
................................................................................................................
The latest podcast in the series of lectures and other events presented by The National Archives of the United Kingdom is on the subject of Emigration records and will be of value to all casahistorians researching family emigration history.
This podcast by Roger Kershaw explains the reasons behind the emigration of some 16 million people since the 17th century. It discusses the most popular destinations for emigrants and sources such as outgoing passenger lists, passport records, and a host of emigration schemes supported and fostered by the government. It also features the various child migration schemes that have been responsible in migrating some 150,000 children from the UK between 1618 and 1967. Particular reference will be made to the growing number of online sources relevant to this subject.
Presentation is worthy, but a little lecture –ish…..
image origin podcast: National Archives
linked casahistoria site: European Emigration
................................................................................................................
Writing the history books in a country which started the Second World War as a dictatorship in alliance with Nazi Germany and then went on to invade and dismember five of its neighbours was always going to be tricky – especially when that same country ended the war on the "other side", proclaiming it was invading eastern Europe (and Manchuria in the Far East) in the name of democracy, liberation and the ending of fascism. Then went on to keep a hold on these territories just as thoroughly as the previous Nazi regime had done…….
So it is hardly a surprise that modern Russia is having problems over the interpretation of the period by those self same neighbours today.
Russia's new President, Dmitry Medvedev has condemned what he described as attempts to rewrite wartime history -- an attack the Kremlin said was aimed at Ukraine and the three Baltic states. In a joint declaration marking the 1941 Nazi invasion of the Soviet Union, Medvedev and Belarussian President Alexander Lukashenko denounced a "politicised approach to history". Their countries "strongly condemn any attempt at rewriting history and revision of the results of World War Two," they said.
Ukraine and the Baltic states Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania have challenged Moscow's view of history, saying their nationals suffered from Soviet as well as Nazi oppression, and a Kremlin spokesman said later the criticism was aimed at them. Meeting in the Belarussian town of Brest, where Nazi forces first crossed the Soviet border on June 22, 1941, the two leaders said that "a selective, politicised approach to history should be set against honest, scientific debate. Only on this basis can Europe draw the lessons of history and avoid a tragic repetition of the errors of the past."
Russia has chided Ukraine for taking steps since the mid-1990s to grant some form of recognition as combatants to the Ukrainian Insurgent Army (UPA), guerrillas who fought both Nazi and Soviet troops to secure an independent state. The issue is contentious in Ukraine, where commemorations expose the country's split into the nationalist west and centre and the Russian-speaking east, more sympathetic to Moscow. Historians say the UPA had 40,000 men in its ranks at its peak. Some Ukrainians donned Nazi uniforms in a unit known as SS Halychyna.
Russia has also complained about Baltic nationalists who resisted Soviet occupation. It became embroiled in a diplomatic row with Estonia last year over the removal of a statue of a Red Army soldier from Tallinn's city centre to a military cemetery. Moscow also says Russian-speaking minorities in Estonia and Latvia have been denied basic rights against a background of strong anti-Russian sentiment.
Perhaps the Russians, and Belarussians have just got to accept that one of the features of the democracy, liberty et al that they announced in 1945 is the ability to consider different interpretations of history…
image origin post source: Herald Tribune
................................................................................................................
Last in December, Aditya Arya, and Indian ad photographer opened some yellow crates he inherited from a photojournalist friend, Kulwant Roy and had left for nearly 25 years. What he discovered was a photographic record of modern Indian history, including thousands of images from the last days of the Raj through the 1960s, many of which have never been published. The archive has now excited historians who believe it may shed new light on key moments in India's independence movement. It has also attracted attention for the commercial value of its images of historical figures ranging from Mahatma Gandhi and Jawaharlal Nehru to Jacqueline Kennedy.
Some of the negatives have become stuck together or begun to disintegrate. Arya has managed to digitally scan and catalogue some 4,000 to 5,000 prints and negatives from Roy's collection, but he estimates this is just a third of the total. Still, several potentially significant photographs have already emerged, including a 1939 picture of Gandhi in a heated argument with Muhammad Ali Jinnah, the head of India's Muslim League who went on to found Pakistan. The two men were seldom photographed together and their disagreements primarily took place out of the public eye.
Roy shot many of Gandhi's travels as well as the 1946 British Cabinet Mission which finalized plans for Indian Independence. And he was there when Lord Louis Mountbatten, the last British viceroy, handed power to Nehru, India's first prime minister. His images may not be as well known as those of photographers like Margaret Bourke-White and Henri Cartier-Bresson, who went to India during this period, but they were popular at the time.
Roy covered Jackie Kennedy's visit in 1962 to India and India's war with Pakistan in 1965. But increasingly, he was eclipsed by a new breed of aggressive young photojournalists. The decorous press conferences and the chummy familiarity with politicians early Indian photojournalists like Roy had enjoyed were giving way to the scrum and the photo-op. Roy hung up his camera.
The photo of Gandhi arguing with Jinnah can be found among the archives of Getty Images, one of the world's largest photo agencies, where it is simply attributed to a "stringer" for Topical Press, a long defunct London news service. "As was common for this period the print was uncredited," Sarah McDonald, a Getty curator, wrote in an e-mail response to questions about the photo. McDonald also wrote that "if we can verify the image is by Roy we will be happy to credit the image to him."
Arya is hoping to mount an exhibition of Roy's photos in Delhi later this year. A book and other projects are also under discussion. Arya believes that some of the images - for instance a picture of a loin-clothed Gandhi descending from a third-class rail car - could become as iconic as the vintage India photos taken by Bourke-White and Cartier-Bresson.
image origin post source: Herald Tribune
linked casahistoria site: Decolonisation
................................................................................................................
Interesting café fact #223:
Numbering an estimated 1.5 million, there are more people of Japanese descent in Brazil than anywhere in the world outside of Japan itself!!
It was exactly one hundred years ago that the first Japanese immigrants arrived in Brazil, and this weekend the country as a whole has been reflecting on the anniversary. The celebrations (with Japan's Crown Prince Naruhito in attendance) are a chance to pay tribute to the pioneering immigrants that first arrived at the port of Santos near to Sao Paulo - and, the organisers say, to thank Brazilian society for making them welcome. The 165 families who arrived here on 18 June 1908 came to escape poverty and lack of job opportunities in Japan, and to meet the demand for workers in Brazil's coffee plantations.
But there is plenty of evidence at the Museum of Japanese Immigration in Sao Paulo that this was not always a comfortable story. The newly-arrived Japanese faced a huge culture shock: a radically different language, food and climate. The aim was to make their fortune quickly and return home - but, for many, it was not to turn out that way. "When they arrived here planting coffee wasn't so productive," says Lidia Yamashita of the Museum of Japanese Immigration in Sao Paulo. "Then, because of World War ll, they could not consider returning to Japan. The expectation changed. They had to stay here in Brazil and think of it as the land where they were going to live."
Few places better illustrate the impact of Brazilians of Japanese descent than in the Liberdade district of Sao Paulo. After years working in the countryside many Japanese immigrants moved to the city to seek a better future. The shops, restaurants, markets and street festivals make Liberdade appear more like part of Tokyo than a Latin American city - and it is now one of Sao Paulo's main attractions. At the weekend this area is packed with people enjoying a wide range of foods, and it is in the eating habits of Brazilians that you can find the most visible evidence of the impact of Japanese immigrants and their descendants. As well as helping to change what had been a very basic diet, they introduced new farming techniques that have helped to make Brazil the agricultural superpower that it is today.
Community leaders say Brazilians of Japanese descent are completely integrated into society here, and that a century after the first immigrants arrived some 40% of their descendants are now mixed race. However, historian Arlinda Rocha Nogueira says this evolution is not complete. "I would not say 100% integrated, no," she says. "They are moving towards a state of integration in the third or fourth generations - but not in the first or second. There are many Japanese societies that are closed."
Interesting café fact #224:
The more that is unearthed about latin american immigration history the less latin it seems to become......
image origin post source: BBC
nearest(!) casahistoria site: Argentine immigration
................................................................................................................
As the closed circuit tv (cctv) cameras breed and multiply on every street, motorway, bridge, airport, and sprout inside buses and trains, shops, hospitals and schools (some of my local secondary schools have cameras inside the toilets - to stop bullying...) the latest irony is that a surveillance cctv camera has now been installed in the Barcelona square, Plaça de George Orwell, that commemorates the civil war volunteer and author of "1984".
Quite what George Orwell himself would have made of it we will never know. But the writer of Nineteen Eighty-Four, the satire featuring the all-seeing eye of Big Brother, might perhaps have been amused to discover a security camera keeping watch over a plaza in Barcelona that bears his name.
The camera monitors any miscreants in this rundown square in the inner-city Ciutat Vella area. Any Orwell pilgrims paying the plaza a visit might be a little disappointed. The square was named after Orwell not because of his literary endeavours, but because he fought on the Republican side in the Spanish civil war. In 1936, he arrived in Spain to fight as part of the International Brigade in the doomed effort to defeat Franco's nationalists. He survived a bullet in the neck before going on to detail the vicious infighting among leftwing factions in Homage to Catalonia. Sixty years later, in 1996, residents of Ciutat Vella marked the anniversary by naming the square after him.
Ciutat Vella contains some of the most popular areas for tourists in the city, so is a magnet for bag thieves. In an effort to crack down on these street robberies, cameras were installed a few years ago. The irony of placing a camera in a square named after Orwell appears to be lost on the local council. "This is a public place independent of the name of the plaza. The camera is there to ensure the security of the individual, not as a measure of repression," says Jaume Cusco, a Barcelona city council spokesman.
image origin post source: Guardian
linked casahistoria site: Spanish Civil War
................................................................................................................
For the last 15 years two key issues of the modern education debate have been how to promote independent learning, (ie encourage learners to learn and discover by themselves) and how to provide effective monitoring of the learning process for student, teacher and parent to help facilitate the best possible progress. A third has been the pragmatic one of how best to achieve this in a cost effective way
One possible way of meeting all three is provided by the experience of Sweden where a private education group, Kunskapsskolan (“Knowledge Schools”) opened its first six schools in 2000. Four more opened last autumn, bringing the total to 30. It now has 700 employees and teaches nearly 10,000 pupils, with an operating profit of SKr62m last year on a turnover of SKr655m.
Like IKEA, the giant Swedish furniture-maker, Kunskapsskolan gets its customers to do much of the work themselves. The vital tool, though, is not an Allen key but the Kunskapsporten (“Knowledge Portal”), a website containing the entire syllabus. Youngsters spend 15 minutes each week with a tutor, reviewing the past week's progress and agreeing on goals and a timetable for the next one. This will include classes and lectures, but also a great deal of independent or small-group study. The Kunskapsporten allows each student to work at his own level, and spend less or more time on each subject, depending on his strengths and weakness. Each subject is divided into 35 steps. Students who reach step 25 graduate with a pass; those who make it to step 30 or 35 gain, respectively, a merit or distinction.
Again like IKEA, no money is spent on fancy surroundings. Kunskapsskolan Enskede, a school for 11- to 16-year-olds in a suburb of Stockholm, is a former office block into which basic classrooms, open-study spaces and two small lecture-theatres have been squeezed. It rents fields nearby for football and basketball, and, like other schools in the chain, sends pupils away to one of two specially built facilities for a week each term for home economics, woodwork and art, rather than providing costly, little-used facilities in the school.
Teachers update and add new material to the website during school holidays and get just seven weeks off each year, roughly the same as the average Swedish office worker. “We don't want teachers preparing lessons during term-time,” says Per Ledin, the company's boss. “Instead we steal that preparation time, and use it so they can spend more time with students.”
One selling point that any parent of a teenager will appreciate is the amount of information they will receive. Each child's progress is reported each week in a logbook, and parents can follow what is being studied on the website. There is an expectation that children take responsibility for their own progress. “Our aim is that by the time students finish school, they can set their own learning goals,” says Christian Wetell, head teacher at Kunskapsskolan Enskede. “Three or four students in each year may not manage this, but most will.”
Performance monitoring is also important within the company: it tracks the performance of individual teachers to see which ones do best as personal tutors or as subject teachers. It offers bonuses to particularly successful teachers and is considering paying extra to good ones from successful schools who are willing to move to underperforming ones.
Kunskapsskolan's do-it-yourself style of education may soon be available outside its home country. In March it was named preferred bidder to run two “academies” (state-funded schools run largely free from state control) in London. If they go ahead, they will be run by a not-for-profit arm, since for-profit ventures are banned from Britain's academies programme.
An interesting concept as outlined by the Economist article but Kunskapsskolan is a commercial firm which also hopes to open low-cost independent schools in Britain, where it can offer the full Kunskapsskolan experience, but free of state involvement. Does this mean they want to be free of state inspection, ie monitoring? That process they are keen to perform on students and staff, but not themselves? We shall need to see.....
image origin post source: Economist
linked casahistoria site: Teaching History
................................................................................................................
The existence or otherwise of statues and monuments are often a good guide to national sensitivities and to changes in public feelings towards a collective past. Where I grew up in Hamburg for example there was/is only one municipal monument to the fallen German troops of the Great War (Kuöhl's 1936 memorial, erected to commemorate those who died in the Franco-Prussian War and the First World War is typical of the ones erected during the Third Reich and is one of the few remaining. The monument, with it's almost mocking inscription, Germany must live, even if we have to die continues to be swathed in controversy, with much public sentiment favouring removing it while others, particularly veterans groups demanding that it remain......) In Spain plaques to the Republican victims of the Civil War have taken 60 years to emerge. Then there are the statue parks of eastern Europe where the great & good of the communist era have been removed to and put out to graze.
In Argentina a historical sensitivity is that of Ernesto "Che" Guevara. While he remains the most famous export of the Argentine city of Rosario, his legacy here has long been a low-key one. Except for a handful of businesses named in his honour, few markers alert visitors that the revolutionary leader was born here exactly 80 years ago before becoming one of the most mythic figures of the 20th century.
That changed this weekend when civic leaders inaugurated the first official monument (click here for more images/background - in Spanish) honouring the revolutionary leader in Argentina, ending decades of government silence about the controversial figure. A 13-foot-high bronze statue unveiled before hundreds of cheering admirers